Home Page Contact Us Site Map
Design Support

Application Notes
Design Examples
Reference Designs
Design Software
Technical Support
IP Licensing
Consultants
Component Suppliers
Design Seminars
Design Seminars



EcoSmart
Energy-Efficient Solutions


 
Does Your Power Supply Bode Well, or Does It Need a Boost?
by Peter Vaughan
Peter Vaughan
  Manager of Product Applications
Power Integrations

Test your power supply printed circuit board layout design skills by trying your hand at answering the three questions below. To enter for a chance to win a new Apple iPod nano, click on the iPod image following Question 3.


The feedback circuit shown in Figure 1a was used for a 24 V, 2.5 A design. The design was created using PI Expert. The bode plots shown in Figure 1b represent loop response without using the components RF4 and CF2.

Figure 1a
.
Figure 1b
Plots in (b) are shown without RFPlots in (b) are shown without RF4 and CF2 in the feedback circuit
 


Which statement(s) best describes the primary function of the feedback loop in a switching power supply?

a) Reduces variation in the output voltage due to tolerances of components such as the transformer inductance and output capacitance.
b) Reduces variation in the output voltage due to variations in the input voltage and/or output load.
c) Improves power supply efficiency.
d) All of the above.
e) None of the above.

 
See the answer to Question 1.

Answer: (a) and (b)
The primary objective of the control loop is to stabilize the power supply against variations in component values over production, as well as variations in line voltage and output load.

When an oscillating power supply is stabilized, there is also an added benefit of increased throughput efficiency. Thus the feedback loop also plays a role in improving the efficiency, although this is not its primary objective.

           Close this answer window.

 

a) What is gain margin and phase margin?
b) Figure 1b shows the bode plot of the partial schematic shown in figure 1a. How much gain margin and phase margin does this design have?

See the answer to Question 2.

(a) For a control loop to become unstable and oscillate two conditions must simultaneously exist:

    1. The phase response from input to output will be -180° (assuming 0° phase shift at DC). 
    2. The loop gain of the system will be 0dB (gain cross over).

Gain margin is the absolute value of the measured loop gain at phase crossover (where the phase has crossed -180°).

Phase margin is the measured phase above—180° at the gain crossover frequency.  The value represents the amount the phase would have to reduce by (that is, lag) to meet the criteria for instability.

A well-designed system should have at least 6 dB of gain margin and 45° to 60° of phase margin.

(b) 1 kHz cross over frequency, 33° Phase margin, and 30 dB gain margin.

           Close this answer window.

a) A phase boost network was added to the circuit in Figure 1a. What does this network accomplish?
b) What is conditional stability and how does it manifest itself in the operation of the power supply?

 
See the answer to Question 3.

(a) The phase boost network adds a pole-zero pair to the controller transfer function. The component values are chosen in such a manner so that the zero is added at a frequency close to the crossover frequency, and the pole is placed a decade apart, thereby increasing the phase margin of the system.

The PI Expert design tool calculates values for feedback components, provides gain phase plots, and recommends when a phase boost network should be used.

(b) The resultant gain and phase response is shown below.  Cross over frequency is 1.1 kHz, the gain margin is 30 dB and phase margin 64°.


Figure 2

Should the phase margin reduce to zero (phase reaches or exceeds –180°) while the gain is greater than zero, then the loop is considered conditionally stable.

Although theoretically a system with a phase margin of 1° is considered stable, in practice the phase margin in a power supply can vary significantly due to component tolerances and line and load variations.

Conditional stability is therefore not desirable, as in this state these variations can cause the loop gain to reduce, shifting the gain cross over to a lower frequency, where phase margin is inadequate, and causing the power supply to become unstable and oscillate.

This often happens during start-up or other load transients, when the control loop commands maximum or minimum duty cycle.

           Close this answer window.

Win an iPod Nano!
iPod Nano
Click here to register!

Copyright 2007 Power Integrations. All rights reserved. Contact Webmaster. Terms of Use | Privacy Policy | Chinese | Japanese | Korean